If you’re searching for an AI tool to help you with your web copy, chances are you’ve stumbled upon some familiar options. And today, we’re pitting two of the hottest writing bots against each other: Quillbot vs. Rytr.
These hardworking engines are quite a hit with digital marketers. But while it’s clear that AI is a big deal in content marketing, search engines still put more weight on helpful and engaging articles.
That said, a human writer can help by transforming cookie-cutter content into a compelling read that creates value and connections.
This post will also explore why AI writing needs heavy editing.
Quillbot vs. Rytr: Full Comparison
Between Quillbot and Rytr, which one is the better writing companion? We’ll help you decide, so read on!
1- Content Quality
Let’s examine how our competing bots stack up to Google’s hallmark of quality content:
Quillbot
At its core, Quillbot is a paraphrasing tool to help you improve your writing. That means it doesn’t generate original content, so it may not be the best option if you want something fresh and unique.
To see how Quillbot holds up, we borrowed content written by Rytr and let Quillbot do its thing. And we must admit it does a remarkable job of rephrasing the articles worthy of Google’s approval.
Rytr
Rytr uses GPT-3 technology to write content that sounds like a human wrote it. The good news is that it can pump out impressive results for shorter articles.
However, some users have complained about the content being repetitive or containing irrelevant information.
So we put Rytr to the test to confirm this. First, we asked it to write a job application email, and it actually did a pretty good job. You only need to tweak a few things to fit your qualifications into the main text.
Next, we assigned it to write a marketing copy about how to revive a dying plant using the AIDA framework. Out of seven sentences, it mentioned the same thing three times: “essential tips,” “simple steps,” and “step-by-step guidance.”
To be fair, it could have sounded better with some trimming.
Winner: It’s a tie!
Quillbot and Rytr speak the same human-like language. No surprise there; both AI writing assistants rely on natural language processing to craft their words.
2- Features & Best Use Cases
Let’s look at the functionality and versatility of these two AI writing aids:
Quillbot
Quillbot is pretty handy when you want to repurpose articles for websites and social media. Academics can use this tool to make complex writing more reader-friendly.
Here’s a brief overview of Quillbot’s capabilities:
- Paraphrase: Rewrite your sentences in seven preset modes and one custom mode.
- Grammar checker: Fix your grammar mistakes via the web app or as a browser plugin.
- Plagiarism checker: Scan your essay for plagiarism and get a detailed PDF report.
- Co-writer: Organize your writing projects and choose from these templates: essay, blog, or research paper.
- Summarizer: Condense your articles down to the key points.
- Citation generator: Generate citations from over 1,800 styles.
- Translator: Translate your copy into 30 languages and regional dialects.
Quillbot lets you paraphrase texts in the following modes:
- Standard: Reword your content as closely as possible to the source.
- Fluency: Aim for highly readable and error-free articles.
- Formal: Format your document for business or academic writing.
- Creative: Rewrite your texts in fresh, inventive ways.
- Shorten: Cut your sentences down to the bare bones.
- Expand: Increase sentence length for more details and depth.
- Custom: Personalize the sound of your rephrased sentences any way you want. For example, you can rewrite texts in the voice of an academic, a Gen Z kid, or a TikTok influencer.
Rytr
Rytr’s platform targets a niche group looking to create content for digital marketing. As such, it offers functionalities specifically designed for this purpose.
Here’s a rundown of Rytr’s best features:
- Grammar checker and autocorrect
- Sentence rephraser
- Built-in plagiarism checker
- Editing tool with options to expand, shorten, and append texts
- Dozens of speech tones and use cases to choose from
- Native SEO toolkit for optimizing content for specific keywords
- Support for over 30 languages
Rytr also allows you to create content for these use cases:
- Business idea
- Blog idea, outline, and section writing
- Landing page and website copies
- Social media ads
- SEO meta title and description
Winner: Rytr
It’s a clear-cut victory for Rytr in this round. If you’re a content marketer, it’s a one-stop shop for all your writing needs!
With options to rephrase, shorten, or expand sentences, you even get Quillbot’s core capabilities as bonuses in Rytr.
Related: here are the top free Rytr alternatives on the market now
3- AI Detection
We put Quillbot- and Rytr-written content through the AI detection wringers for a spin. Check out the result of our little experiment:
Quillbot
Because Quillbot cannot write its own content, we tasked Rytr with generating a blog section about how to fix undercooked banana bread. Next, we paraphrased the copy in Quillbot in simple mode. Then, we ran the output through GPTZero, Copyleaks, and ZeroGPT.
And guess what?
All three AI detection tools came to the same conclusion: the text is highly likely to be AI-generated.
Rytr
We asked Rytr to whip up an informative blog post about how to host a dinner party on a budget. Again, our trusty AI detectors detected the content to be entirely AI-written.
Winner: None
Quillbot and Rytr are good at mimicking human writing for shorter articles, but there was no fooling these AI detection engines.
Both tools still have much catching up to do to achieve the natural flow of human language, particularly in long-form writing.
4- Ease of Use
Let’s see how Quillbot and Rytr match up when it comes to their user-friendliness:
Quillbot
The paraphrasing wizard has a minimalist and intuitive dashboard, with the main menu neatly stacked on the left side. You can collapse the menu items into tiny icon buttons if you want extra space on the main screen.
A helpful tip will appear when you hover over any clickable option, making the interface a breeze to learn and navigate.
Also, Quillbot offers tons of self-learning resources, including a help center and a comprehensive paraphrasing guide.
Rytr
Rytr’s user interface has the same clean and sleek look as Quillbot’s. The flow is straightforward and simplifies the copywriting process.
Rytr has three sets of menus: Copy, Image, and Chat. We’ll focus on the Copy mode, which is the default and where Rytr generates content.
Before Rytr starts “ryting,” you have to set up the following:
- Language
- Tone
- Use case
- Topic
- Keywords
- Number of variants (1 to 3)
- Creativity level (none to optimal)
Getting started with Rytr is quick and easy; you only need to experiment with tone and use case options to find the writing that best fits your needs.
Winner: QuillBot
Rytr has a more sophisticated user interface. Enough said!
Recommended: here’s our extensive Content Gorilla AI review
5- Support
Now, let’s compare how Quillbot and Rytr treat their customers:
Quillbot
You can connect with Quillbot through different channels:
- Contact Us page
- Social media
- Discord
Unfortunately, users complain about nonresponsive and sluggish customer support. Canceling your subscription as a new paying customer can be frustrating because of the brief money-back window.
Not only that, but users also report that Quillbot renews plans without proper notification.
Rytr
Rytr boasts a consistent 4.9 rating from thousands of Trustpilot and Appsumo reviews. Not to mention, the customer support team is especially attentive to unsatisfied customers.
What’s more, submitting a report ticket means you can expect a resolution within 24 hours.
Winner: Rytr
What can we say? Rytr has serious street cred when it comes to customer support.
6- Pricing
Lastly, you’ll want to know which AI writing assistant gives more bang for your buck.
Quillbot
Quillbot has a free trial that includes the following:
- Max of 125 words in the paraphraser
- Up to 1200 words in the summarizer
- One Freeze word/phrase
- Three synonym options
- Access to standard and fluency modes
You can also subscribe to the premium plan, which is available in three subscription options:
- Monthly: $19.95
- Semi-annual: $79.95 ($39.75 savings)
- Annual: $99.95 ($139.45 savings)
You can unlock several features with the paid plan, such as:
- Unlimited use of the paraphraser and freeze words/phrases
- Up to 6,000 words in the summarizer
- All writing modes
- Full use of the Synonym Slider (four synonym options)
- Plagiarism checker (scans up to 20 pages/month)
If you are unhappy with Quillbot or realize you don’t need it after subscribing, Quillbot offers a three-day money-back guarantee. You’ll get a full refund if you request it within three days of purchase and haven’t received a refund before.
Rytr
Not to be outdone, Rytr also offers a free plan with the following perks:
- 10,000 characters per month
- Over 40 use cases, 30 languages, and 20 tones
- Built-in plagiarism checker
- Up to five AI-generated images per month
If you need more, the Saver plan costs $9/month and $90/year for a monthly limit of 100,000 characters.
And if you need even more, there’s the Unlimited plan at $29/month and $290/year.
Plus, you’ll get two months free if you sign up for any annual plan!
Winner: Rytr
Both AI-powered tools have a free trial to test some features before committing to a paid plan. Here’s a comparison of the freebies:
- Rytr can generate 1500–2000 words based on the free 10,000 characters. Quillbot offers only 1,325.
- You’ll have access to only two modes with Quillbot. Meanwhile, all the use cases, tones, and languages in Rytr’s paid plans are also available in the free version.
- Unlike Quillbot, you can use Rytr’s built-in plagiarism checker for free. To scan more content in Quillbot, you’ll have to buy extra pages.
While Quillbot’s annual plan seems like a steal, Rytr ultimately gets the upper hand.
Overall Winner: Rytr
It all boils down to one thing—Quillbot is a paraphrasing tool, not a true AI copywriter like Rytr.
Quillbot is reliable for refining existing content, while Rytr generates content from scratch. With features like the ability to produce multiple copies with varying levels of creativity, Rytr’s AI technology offers much more flexibility than Quillbot’s.
On top of that, Rytr has reliable customer support!
Related: Rytr & Writesonic head-to-head comparison
Why Do You Need an AI Editing Service?
We all love a good shortcut, and AI tools are the ultimate hack for writing. In fact, the Associated Press has been automating news stories for over ten years. Now, everyone can access machines that sound like your nerdy, polite next-door neighbor—but on steroids!
But as impressive as AI writing sidekicks are, they’re not perfect. Even the most brilliantly sounding AI-written content could use some good ‘ol human touch. And that’s where an AI content editing service comes in!
Here’s another thing: Google hates spam (not the luncheon meat)! So much that it punishes sites for spammy content and behaviors. Again, you need human editors to ensure your AI-written copy doesn’t fall into that trap.
Still not convinced? Here are the top reasons why you can’t rely on AI copywriters solely for your web content:
1- AI Hallucinates Information
Picture AI writing tools on some digital speed, cranking out words in record time. And just like the street drug, over-dependence on them can lead to trippy consequences—hallucinations!
That’s right—your favorite writing wizard hallucinates information. When they do, they imagine things that never happened or don’t exist and pass them off as cold, hard truths. The scarier part is that they talk about them with unwavering confidence and authority.
For example, a physicist fabricated some fancy shoptalk and asked ChatGPT about it. Lo and behold—the chatbot crafted a plausible-sounding answer! Google’s Bard also embarrassed itself when it said the James Webb space telescope took the first pictures of an exoplanet.
Remember, misinformation can sow confusion and distrust, and nobody wants to be fed a bunch of baloney. So, double-check your facts to avoid spreading lies. A human editor can help you catch those errors, so don’t discount them from the equation just yet!
2- AI Often Writes Plagiarized Content
Think of AI as a smooth-talking parrot with a mega-library’s worth of vocabulary. Here’s the snag: The bot can spit out borrowed content without crediting sources.
Take the case of CNET. The tech media outlet received heat after their AI author botched financial articles left and right. They lifted snippets from published work without giving them props.
That’s scraped content, per Google’s standards, and scraped content equals spam. You can’t just change words or use synonyms to get around it.
And do you know what else Google doesn’t like? Auto-generated web copies without any human oversight. So, don’t get your hands caught in the plagiarism cookie jar. Quillbot and Rytr both have a plagiarism checker you can use to scan your copy for unoriginal text.
And if you want 100% authentic material, let our human editors help you. We’ll ensure to add your unique value and not spin content from other feeds.
3- AI Is Repetitive
AI writing assistants can produce grammatically correct sentences like nobody’s business. But don’t expect them to write Pulitzer-winning prose for you!
Some stuff that AI writes sounds like a broken record. Thankfully, you can jazz up monotonous AI-written text with the help of an AI editing service.
And when you work with us, our human editors will go over your copies with a fine-toothed comb. You can count on us to weed out anything that doesn’t enhance the user experience!
4- AI Has a Biased Algorithm
Researchers tested ChatGPT using a questionnaire and discovered its left-leaning biases on socio-political issues. Of note is that the bot’s responses to the same question would vary at different times.
And if partisan chatbots aren’t bad enough, they might end up saying racist and sexist stuff, too. Here’s some proof: A university head got a chatbot to write computer code that said only Asian or white males would make good scientists.
Of course, these biases aren’t intentional. AI systems are only as good as their training data. In other words, if the data contains harmful stereotypes, the AI will learn them.
Our human editors can keep your writing in check, removing anything offensive that sneaks past the AI engine’s filters.
5- AI Lacks Human Depth and Complexity
AI writing assistants can churn out words a hundred times faster than a caffeine-fueled writer on a deadline. But they still have miles to go before they can match the creative flair of a human author.
First, AI tools cannot compete with our imagination and depth. They can be generic and impersonal, lacking the emotions and personality to connect with readers. While the AI gods scramble to teach them to write in different tones, the flow can still fall flat.
Second, AI has a limited understanding of context. It may struggle to grasp the subtleties of a particular field, leading to errors and inaccuracies. It’s more problematic in specialized industries that use specific jargon.
Human writers are better equipped to infuse their writing with unique perspectives that resonate with the audience. That said, a well-rounded content strategy should harness both AI tools and human editors for an engaging and accurate final product.
Related: Jasper vs. GoCharlie full comparison
Wrapping Up
AI writing can make you feel like a literary genius in a flash. But issues like hallucinations, repetitiveness, and discriminatory content can slip through, turning your masterpiece into a disaster just as fast.
So, before you hit that publish button, let our human editors give your AI-generated text a once-over. We’ll swoop in to fact-check and polish your AI-generated text to perfection. Plus, we’ll ensure you sail through even the most sophisticated AI detection tools.
Keep your brand image intact and your content top-notch. Don’t settle for formulaic, robotic writing. Give our AI editing services a try today!